Our Menu
Classic & Specialty Pizzas
Pizza Divinci
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Our signature red sauce with fresh tomatoes, spinach, ricotta & mozzarella.
Garlic Garden
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Delicious garlic sauce with mozzarella, spinach, Spanish onions & fresh tomatoes.
Elite Eight
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Our signature red sauce with mozzarella, pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, mushrooms, peppers, Spanish onions & olive.
Pizza Sicillia
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Our signature red sauce, Spanish onions, hot peppers, pepperoni, Italian sausage & pecorino Romano.
Hot Honey Pie
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Your Choice of Three Toppings, White or Red Sauce, Mozzarella & Drizzled with Hot Honey.
Veggie Weggie
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Our signature red sauce with mozzarella, bell peppers, mushrooms & Spanish onions.
Buffalo Chicken Pie
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Diced crispy chicken made with our authentic buffalo wing sauce, topped with mozzarella & served with bleu cheese.
Great Steak-Out Pie
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Our signature red sauce with mozzarella, sauteed steak, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and drizzled with country sweet sauce.
Our Famous Deluxe
$17.95/+
10" 6 Slices $17.95 | 12" 8 Slices $21.95 | 14" 10 Slices 25.95 | 16" 12 Slices $28.95 | Sheet Pizza 32 Slices $39.95 • Our signature red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers & Spanish onions.
Traditional Pizzas
Toppings: Pepperoni • Meatballs • Grilled Chicken • Italian Sausage • Ham • Anchovies • Bacon • Eggs Sweet Peppers • Hot Peppers • Roasted Peppers • Jalapenos • Hot Cherry Peppers • Spinach • Mushrooms • Onions • Broccoli • Tomatoes • Black Olives • Pineapple
Artichoke Hearts • Cheddar • Ricotta • Extra Mozzarella
Personal 10"
$12.95
6 Slices Cheese | Toppings 1.69 ea.
Personal 12"
$16.95
8 Slices Cheese | Toppings 2.39 ea.
Personal 14"
$18.95
10 Slices Cheese | Toppings 2.79 ea.
Personal 16"
$20.95
12 Slices Cheese | Toppings 2.99 ea.
Personal/Sheet
$29.99
32 Slices Cheese | Toppings 3.89 ea.
Calzones
Toppings: Pepperoni • Meatballs • Grilled Chicken • Italian Sausage • Ham • Anchovies • Bacon • Eggs Sweet Peppers • Hot Peppers • Roasted Peppers • Jalapenos • Hot Cherry Peppers • Spinach • Mushrooms • Onions • Broccoli • Tomatoes • Black Olives • Pineapple
Mozzarella & Ricotta
$15.29
1.09 Additional Toppings
Specialty Calzones
$18.95
See descriptions for Specialty Pizzas
Pizza Divinci
$18.95
Our Signature Red Sauce with Fresh Tomatoes, Spinach, Ricotta & Mozzarella.
Garlic Garden
$18.95
Delicious Garlic Sauce with Mozzarella, Spinach, Spanish Onions & Fresh Tomatoes.
Elite Eight
$18.95
Our Signature Red Sauce with Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Ham, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Peppers, Spanish Onions & Olives.
Pizza Sicillia
$18.95
Our Signature Red Sauce, Spanish Onions, Hot Peppers, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage & Pecorino Romano.
Hot Honey
$18.95
Your Choice of Three Toppings, White or Red Sauce, Mozzarella & Drizzled with Hot Honey.
Veggie Weggie
$18.95
Our Signature Red Sauce with Mozzarella, Bell Peppers, Mushrooms & Spanish Onions.
Buffalo Chicken
$18.95
Diced Crispy Chicken made with Our Authentic Buffalo Wing Sauce, topped with Mozzarella & served with Bleu Cheese.
Great Steakout
$18.95
Sautéed Steak, Mushrooms, Peppers, Onion, Garlic Sauce & Mozzarella, drizzled with Country Sweet Sauce.
Our Famous Deluxe
$18.95
Our Signature Red Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Bell Peppers & Spanish Onions.
Wings & Fingers
Served with Bleu Cheese Dressing | Choose from: Authentic Buffalo (mild or hot), Barbecue, Country Sweet, Mango
Habanero, Nashville Hot, or Garlic Parmigiano
5 Regular Wings
$8.49
Includes 1 bleu cheese dip.
10 Regular Wings
$15.95
Includes 1 bleu cheese dip.
15 Regular Wings
$29.95
Includes 1 bleu cheese dip.
20 Regular Wings
$29.95
Includes 2 bleu cheese dips.
1/2 lb Boneless
$8.49
Includes 1 bleu cheese dip.
Full 1 lb Boneless
$16.49
Includes 2 bleu cheese dips.
Chicken Fingers & Fries
$14.95
Generous order of tender chicken fingers with our tavern-style fries and your choice of dipping sauce.
5 Jumbo Wings & Side
$12.95
5 jumbo wings & a side of your choice.
Shareables
$3.00 OFF any Shareable with the purchase of any pizza!
Loaded Fries
$11.29
Full 1 lb. of tavern-style fries with bacon, mozzarella & cheddar.
Mozzarella Sticks
$9.89
7 breaded mozzarella sticks with our signature red sauce.
10pc. Jumbo Wings
$14.95
Tossed with your favorite sauce.
1 lb. of Boneless Wings
$14.95
Tossed with your Favorite Sauce
Onion Ring Basket
$9.29
A generous portion of thick-sliced battered onions.
Pizza Logs
$11.29
4 pizza logs served with our signature red sauce.
Cheesy Garlic Bread
$8.99
Garlic bread topped with mozzarella and cheddar.
Bay Goodman Platter
$16.95
2 pizza logs, 2 chicken fingers, 2 mozzarella sticks, French fries, onion rings & your choice of 2 sauces.
Hoagies
10" Fresh Hoagie Roll
Meatball
$13.95
Your Choice of House-Made Meatballs or Crispy Chicken Parmigiano, Topped with Mozzarella & Our Signature Red Sauce.
Chicken Parmigiano
$13.95
Your Choice of House-Made Meatballs or Crispy Chicken Parmigiano, Topped with Mozzarella & Our Signature Red Sauce.
Great Steak-Out
$13.95
Shaved Steak, Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, Provolone & Country Sweet Sauce.
Goodman Delight
$13.95
Your Choice of Grilled Chicken or Shaved Steak with Mushrooms, Artichoke Hearts, Light Garlic Sauce & Provolone.
Steak in The Grass
$13.95
Shaved Steak, Spinach, Onions, Hot Banana Peppers, Light Garlic Sauce & Provolone.
Buffalo Chicken
$13.95
Crispy Chicken Tossed in Our Authentic Buffalo Wing Sauce, then covered in Mozzarella & Bleu Cheese.
"My Way" Cheesesteak
$13.95
Shaved Steak with your choice of Cheese, Toppings & Dressing.
Bay Burger
$13.95
Over 3/4 LB. of Fresh Grill-Pressed Burger with Extra Bacon, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo.
Chicken Sandwiches
Bay Goodmans Chicken Deluxe
$8.95
Breaded or Grilled Chicken Breast, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo.
Chicken Parm
$8.95
Italian Breaded Chicken Breast, Provolone Cheese & B&G Marinara Sauce.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
$10.95
Breaded or Grilled Chicken Breast with Honey-Smoked Bacon, American Cheese & Ranch Dressing.
Nashville Hot
$8.95
Breaded Chicken Breast coated with Nashville Hot Sauce, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo.
Fresh Wraps
Bambino
$13.95
Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Provolone, Lettuce, Ranch Dressing.
Buffalo Chicken
$13.95
Strip-Sliced Chicken Tenders, Bleu Cheese, Buffalo Wing Sauce, Lettuce & Mozzarella.
Goodman Delight
$13.95
Fresh Sliced Steak, Mushrooms, Artichokes, Lettuce & Mozzarella.
"My Way"
$13.95
Choose your favorite ingredients to create your own mouth-watering Wrap.
Great Steak-Out
$13.95
Shaved Steak, Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, Lettuce, Provolone & Country Sweet Sauce
Margherita
$13.95
Fresh Tomato, Basil, Lettuce, Mozzarella & Extra Virgin Oi.
Pisano
$13.95
Meatballs, Tomato, Roasted Peppers, Lettuce, Provolone & Our House-Made Oil.
Grilled Chicken Caesar
$13.95
Sliced Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Asiago, Red Onions, Lettuce & Caesar Dressing.
Plates
Great Plates $14.89 | Served with choice of 2: Macaroni Salad, Home Fries, French Fries
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Italian Sausage
Steak
Chicken Finger
Smash Burgers
Angus beef | Featuring our fresh grill-pressed beef
Rochester Burger
$8.95
Topped with American Cheese, Mustard, Onions & Our Own Meat Hot Sauce.
All-American Burger
$8.95
Topped with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions & Mayo.
Bacon Jam Smash Burger
$12.95
Double Burger, Double Cheese, Bacon, topped with Habanero Bacon Jam.
Cowboy Smash Burger
$12.95
Double Burger, Double Cheese, Bacon, Onion Rings with Sweet Baby Ray BBQ.
Bacon Cheeseburger
$10.75
Topped with Bacon, American Cheese, Ketchup, Mustard, Onions & Pickles.
"My Way" Burger
$8.95
Topped with Any or All of Your Favorites – truly made“Your Way”! Add Bacon for 2.00
Salads
Add Grilled Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Crispy Chicken or Steak to any salad for just $3.00
House Salad
$10.89
Crisp Romaine, Red Onions, Tomatoes, Red & Green Peppers, Black Olives, Shredded Asiago & Our House Italian Dressing.
Caesar Salad
$12.89
Crisp Romaine, Red Onions, Bacon, Seasoned Croutons & Shredded Asiago.
Mediterranean Salad
$13.89
Crisp Romaine, Roasted Red Peppers, Red Onions,Artichoke Hearts, Black Olives & Shredded Asiago.
Chopped Veggie Salad
$13.89
Crisp Romaine, Mushrooms, Red & Green Peppers, Spinach, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Broccoli & Our Famous Original Bay & Goodman House Vinaigrette.
Sides
2 oz. extra dressing or marinara, add 1.00
French Fries
$5.89
House Salad
$5.98
Caesar Salad
$5.89
Garlic Knots
$5.89
Onion Rings
$5.89
Desserts
Pizza Fritta (Fried Dough)
$6.89
Brownie (2 pc.)
$6.89
Two Cannolis
$6.89